The Kamanga Project

SHARE:

Aerial shot of the ongoing construction of Coal fired power plant in Kamanga Maasim, Sarangani Province
photo by gmanetwork.com

   The Kamanga coal fired power plant project divides the opinion of the public. Up until now, this controversial venture is still on the public scrutiny. The proponents and its opposition are still on debate whether this project will be beneficial or just another form of capitalism branded as the answer to the power crisis. The government said that the power crisis will be gone in 2015 but the environmentalists are still skeptical about it. 

   “The Kamanga power station (also known as the Southern Mindanao power station or the SM200 project) is a 210-megawatt (MW) coal-fired power station owned by Sarangani Energy Corp (SEC) and under construction on the coast of Sarangani Province. It is one of two coal plants under development by Alcantara family energy-related businesses.”

   The proponents of this project are confident that it will solve the power crisis in Mindanao. This project will initially generate 200 megawatts of electricity with two incremental expansions of 350 MW over a period of 15 years. Moreover the project will spur economic development and generates employment.

   The Kamanga coal power plant project will not only benefit the consumers of General Santos City, Sarangani Province and South Cotabato, but also Butuan City, the cities of Tagum and Samal in Davao del Norte, the entire province of Agusan del Sur, and the entire province of Compostela Valley.

   Joseph C. Nocos, Conal Holdings vice president, gave assurances that the project will comply with national and international environment guidelines. "We can't let our massive investments go down the drain by being irresponsible in our operations," the company official said.

   In a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), Conal Holdings and Maasim “committed to reforest, rehabilitate and develop Maasim’s vast brush lands, grasslands and forestlands for the establishment of a natural carbon sink for the company’s coal-fired power plant”. As stated in MOU, “Conal is committed to support the development of tree farms, small scale agro-forestry systems and tree plantations as carbon sink with the different tenure holders and legitimate forest occupants in the forestlands of Maasim.”


Photo by barangayrp.wordpress.com


Environmentalist’s plea 

   The recent incident of coral destruction in the area of Maasim caught the attention not only to the environmentalists but also to the concerned citizens. The six hectares of naturally and artificially grown corals are being destroyed due to the ongoing construction of the coal fired power plant situated in Kamanga Maasim, Sarangani Province. 

   The coral destruction upsets many environmentalists. Since Sarangani Bay is already polluted with industrial waste and improper agricultural activities in the upland areas, they make actions and solutions to help save the Sarangani Bay. 

   According to John Heitz, coral formations as big as sedans were dragged and uprooted by cables that now anchor four barges in Kamanga in Maasim, site of 100-megawatt coal fired power plant owned by the Alcantara’s Sarangani Energy Corporation (SEC). He already wrote Equipment Engineers Inc. (EEI), one of the sub-contractors of the Korean-owned Dailem Philippines Inc. which won in the bid to construct the US$250-million project. John Heitz along with other divers and environmentalists are putting their effort to rehabilitate the Sarangani bay. 

  Chris Dearne, a former British soldier turned dive-instructor/environmentalist, a substantial area of the reefs along the western coast of the bay are practically dead, especially the Glan area of Cabug, Kapatan and Lago, due to dap-ag and pollution. He along with other divers conducts coastal clean-up driven where they’ve collected non-biodegradable materials like plastics, cellphones, car tires, nylon ropes, bottles, caps, Styrofoam that were recovered even from offshore. He also said that the western part of the bay is “still saveable”, from a portion in barangay Bawing in General Santos City towards Maitum town in Sarangani. He also said that the eastern part of the coast, from barangay Tambler, General Santos, to the towns of Alabel, Malapatan and Glan in Sarangani, has been plaqued with chemicals and other pollutants from agriculture and industries. “Logging for lumber and large-scale charcoal making in the mountains of Alabel and Malapatan towns have taken its toll on the coral reefs and the bay’s marine life”, he added. 

   Dearne laments the insensitivity of government agencies and the people who have sworn to protect nature and environment. He said it was only lately that leaders of government are taking interest on the issue, when everyone is talking about climate change and deterioration in the environment. 

   Paul Partridge, a dive instructor and owner of Southpoint resort, also commented on the Kamanga Coal Power Plant Project. He said, “Everything has its effects. It is only a matter of putting trust on duly established standards and laws,” Partridge said coal may not be the cleanest, but, there are technologies, laws and standards that would ensure a less expensive alternative for power. 

   Many environmental groups like Greenpeace and other church-backed organizations have been opposing the construction of coal-fired power plants on concerns over human health and the environment. 

   According to Greenpeace coal is the “biggest industrial contributors to microscopic particulate pollution”, citing studies on the effects of coal-powered plants and found acid gas, soot and dust emissions contribute hugely to pollution. Its effects are increased risks in heart attacks, lung cancer, asthma and other respiratory problems. 

   The Union of Concerned Scientists said that burning coal is a leading cause of smog, acid rain, global warming, and air toxics. In an average year, a typical coal plant generates: 

• 3,700,000 tons of carbon dioxide (CO2), the primary human cause of global warming--as much carbon dioxide as cutting down 161 million trees. 
• 10,000 tons of sulfur dioxide (SO2), which causes acid rain that damages forests, lakes, and buildings, and forms small airborne particles that can penetrate deep into lungs. 
• 500 tons of small airborne particles, which can cause chronic bronchitis, aggravated asthma, and premature death, as well as haze obstructing visibility. 
• 10,200 tons of nitrogen oxide (NOx), as much as would be emitted by half a million late-model cars. NOx leads to formation of ozone (smog) which inflames the lungs, burning through lung tissue making people more susceptible to respiratory illness. 
• 720 tons of carbon monoxide (CO), which causes headaches and place additional stress on people with heart disease. 
• 220 tons of hydrocarbons, volatile organic compounds (VOC), which form ozone. 
• 170 pounds of mercury, where just 1/70th of a teaspoon deposited on a 25-acre lake can make the fish unsafe to eat. 
• 225 pounds of arsenic, which will cause cancer in one out of 100 people who drink water containing 50 parts per billion. 
• 114 pounds of lead, 4 pounds of cadmium, other toxic heavy metals, and trace amounts of uranium. 

   In article of Kyle Laskowski entitled Coal power: Pollution, politics, and profits, he stated that: 

“Some negative externalities arise from the use of coal as a primary electricity source. Negative health effects on the nearby human population, plant life, and wildlife have been hard to quantify precisely and thoroughly, and are generally not included in the cost of coal power to the consumer…. Some developing nations are not so forward-looking on this issue, choosing to allow the industry to emit toxins unhindered because that is the cheaper alternative. It is hard to blame the poorest nations for their relative lack of environmental standards because they are doing the best they can to advance to a better standard of living. However, it is possible to advance towards more healthy energy sources without sacrificing very much wealth. If the developed world aided impoverished nations more, this problem could be alleviated to some extent.” 

   Thermal pollution is also feared when the power plant will be operational. The power plant might trigger discharges from its cooling system that may eventually alter water temperature. As Laskowski stated in his article: 

“When warm water used to cool a coal power plant is exhausted into bodies of water that harbor life, it becomes thermal pollution which can have negative effects on the ecosystem. Heating a body of water decreases its dissolved oxygen content, which has the potential to harm animals dependent on it for oxygen. Heating also leads to an increase in the metabolic rate of the organisms living in the body of water, causing them to require more food. Warmer waters can trigger algae blooms, further depriving the water of oxygen.” 

   Juland Suazo, spokesperson of the environment group Panalipdan critiqued the government’s switch from renewable energy to coal-powered plants. “With greater coal power comes increased electricity rates like what happened in Luzon and Visayas. The reason why Mindanao has cheaper rates compared to Luzon and Visayas is because we use renewable energy from Agus-Pulangi hydropower plants,” he added. He also criticized Aquino who launched on 2011 the National Renewable Energy Plan (NREP) but is now pushing for what he calls “dirty energy” of coal-fired power plants with contracts granted through private-public partnership.


Photovoltaic array and wind turbines at the Schneebergerhof wind farm in the German state of Rheinland-Pfalz
photo by wikipedia.org


The case of Germany 

   Many developed countries are pushing for renewable energy sources. For example, Germany is gradually phasing out their nuclear power to give way to more sustainable source of energy like solar and wind power. In an article written by Rainer Backe entitled Germany’s Energiewende: The Prospects of a Grand-Scale Project, he said: 

“Germany is gradually phasing out their nuclear energy source. The country is investing on renewable energy sources such as solar and wind. Germany is the first major industrial country to seriously consider the challenge of overcoming the entire range problems associated with fossil and nuclear fuels – from emissions to cost from nuclear proliferation to nuclear waste, from environmental devastation to health impacts.” 

   Other European countries are pushing for renewable energy. Austria, Switzerland, Norway, Denmark, Sweden, Belgium and France are also developing renewable-based economies. Though these countries have a long way to go to achieve their goals for sustainable power source, they are determined and willing to invest for the future. Germany is leading this trend, as Backe noted: 

“If Germany, despite medium irradiation levels, limited land grow biomass, and average wind and water resources, succeeds in the transforming the energy system to renewable sources while keeping an eye on cost, then every other country in the world will be able to follow on that track, too. And challenges entailed for these countries will be significantly lower.”


photo by theguardian.com

Conclusion 


   The issue of power crisis in the Philippines is very complex. Writing this article is not enough to explain or evaluate its complexities. As citizens in this country, we should be vigilant and proactive consumers. In the case of Germany, there is a broad social consensus among the majority of the Germans. Its citizens are actively participating in their energiewende program.

   It is sad to know that our government is favoring non-renewable sources of energy over renewable energy. The EPIRA Law marks the end of renewable power source. This law is supposed to be a relief to the consumers but it turns out to be a burden. 

   On the other hand, we cannot blame the proponents of coal since this source of energy is “fairly inexpensive and abundant fuel source”. The problem lies in accountability, transparency and the politics behind it. When I first heard this project, I am wondering why there is no proper public consultation about it. If there’s a series of consultation, only limited or chosen people were invited. The power plant’s Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) was not publicly published or disseminated properly. The majority of people in SOCSKSARGEN (especially in Sarangani) are still confused about it. It seems that this project was kept secret until we were surprise that a structure was built (and still building) in the shoreline of Maasim. 

   As consumers, we should demand for their mitigation measures on how they are going to solve future problems. We should demand for accountability and transparency. In this stage, we can no longer stop the construction of the power plant since it was already approved. Not unless there is a major power plant disaster or a Godzilla like figure suddenly appear on the scene.






References

Edwin Espejo. Ongoing construction of power plant in Sarangani destroying corals, divers say. - May 11, 2014 1:24 PM - InterAksyon.com

Rommel G. Rebollido. Not man, but nature itself destroys Sarangani Bay. June 22, 2009 8:50 am - http://balita.ph/2009/06/22/not-man-but-nature-itself-destroys-sarangani-bay/

Kamanga power station - http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Kamanga_power_station

Kyle Laskowski. Coal power: Pollution, politics, and profits. OCTOBER 13, 2010. http://www.visionofearth.org/featured-articles/coal-power-pollution-politics-and-profits/

Union of Concerned Scientists. Why Coal-Fired Power is Bad.
http://www.sustainablearizona.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1175&Itemid=2

Allen V. Estabillo. Coal-fired power firm plans carbon sink. July 16, 2008. MindaNews.com

Tyrone A. Velez. Pushing coal-fired power plants in Mindanao for profit. August 11 2013.
http://davaotoday.com/main/2013/08/11/pushing-coal-power-plants-in-mindanao-for-profit/

Rainer Backe. Germany’s Energiewende: The Prospects of a Grand-Scale Project. Georgetown Journal of International Affairs: The Future of Energy. Winter/Spring 2013


GreenPeace Philippines - http://www.greenpeace.org/seasia/ph/





Leave a comment below and let me know what you think.
Thank you

COMMENTS

BLOGGER
This is the blog of G.V. Alfasain (or popularly known as Yadu Karu) where he shares his thoughts about current events, sustainable development and pop culture. He also shares success stories of modern day heroes to inspire his readers. The author hopes that this blog may contribute change in the (Philippine) society.
Name

action film adventure advertising advocacy agriculture Alabel anniversary APL-SENTRO apology ARMM Art ASEAN Aswang Ateneo de Davao University audition B'laan BANGSAMORO Bangsi Festival banlas Beach behind the scenes BFAR Binex Financial Times Biography Blaan blog Bloggers bloopers Bo's Coffee Bob Ong book review Books Bourne series boxing Brigada Station Brillante Mindoza British films Business business books Business Chamber BWC calamity CARAT career Carl Jung cashflow CDs chat CHED China vs. Philippines Chiz Escudero Cinema Rehiyon Cinemalaya climate change coal power plant coffee shop comedy film community service computer concert conflict consultation contest copper Cotabato City crime Critical analysis culture Cybercrime Law DAR Davao City Davao Region democracy Department of Agriculture Department of Environment and Natural Resources Department of Tourism DepEd Doc Cagape documentary film DOE DOLE DoleFil drama DTI DVDs Economic Development Committee Ecotrek Education Eid al-Fitr Election Elizabethan entrepreneur environment Europe event experiment faith fantasy film farmers Fashion Ferdinand Marcos Festival Filipino books Filipino films film film festival film reviews film workshop filmmaking fishing industry flooding Food trip forum Framework Agreement friend game GAS Generals Generation Change Project Gensan Gensan Doctor's Hospital GenSan Library GenSan Water District Glan gold Google Google Business Group Google Mapping Google Philippines GPH Grace Poe graduate Greenpeace GSCCI Gumasa Beach gun-for-hire HABI HABI Volunteers health heritage holiday Hollywood Holy Trinity College horror film Human Rights Iguoi Production Indi film Indigenous People Information Technology international internet interview investing IP Islam job Job Fair joint exercise Jollibee journalism Kabacan kabit Kawas Beach KCC Mall Kiamba Kinam Koronadal City Labor Code Labor Day Lady Gaga Lagao Gym Lake Sebu leadership LGBT LGU Maasim Maguindanao Maitum Malapatan Malaysia Malls Manny Pacquiao Marin Martial Law Marvel Studio media medical book medical mission meeting message Midsayap MILF Military MinDA Mindanao minerals mining MNLF MSU-GenSan Munato Festival Muslim Muslim Reformist National Bookstore National Sunrise Festival National Youth Commission NCCA netizens networking business news NGO NGOs Nora Aunor North Cotabato Nur Misuari OFW OPAPP open-pit mining opinion opportunity Organic Farming Paco Evangelista Pagadian City PAMANA PCCI peace peace agreement People pharma Philippine Government Philippine Heart Center Philippine Heart Foundation philippines photo photo blog photo shoot photography photoJourn PICOS MACHINE Pilipinas Got Talent Pnoy policy Polomolok pop culture Power Crisis praying press release PressCon projects promotional photos propaganda protest psychology books QUEST Ramadan Real Estate reality show Region XII Regional Development Council remote areas reporting research Resident Evil resto RH Bill Rodrigo Duterte rollerblades Rudrigo Duterte Sabah SalaMindanaw Asian Film Festival SalaMindanaw Film SalaMindanaw Film Festival SalaMindanaw International Film Festival Sarangani Sarangani Bay Fest Sarangani Big Brother Scarborough Shoal school sci-fi SDS seminar SFFAI Inc. Shakespeare short film SK skaters SM Mall Gensan SM Malls SM Supermarket Gensan small-scale mining SME SMI SOCCSARGEN SOCCSARGEN BLOGGERS SOCCSKSARGEN Social Media SOCOTECO II South China Sea Dispute South Cotabato SOX SP GenSan SPNI sports Starbucks Sto Niño strategic plan Sufu Sultan Kudarat Sulu Archipelago Sulu Sultanate Summit Sun City Suites Surallah sustainable developement sustainable development T'nalak festival Tampakan Tboli Team Bundol Team PNoy teaser trailer text scare threats Tourism trade travel tree planting tribe Tuanadatu Tuna Tuna Festival Tuna Industry tv typhoon U.P. U.S Embassy U.S.-Philippines Union Union Workers United States University UPRC video Video City vigilant citizen visual art Vlogging Vmobile volunteerism vote Wajahat Ali workshop world World Water Day writing Yadu Karu's Blog Yaman Gensan youth youth development youth empowerment Zamboanga City Zamboanga del Sur zipline zombies
false
ltr
item
Yadu Karu's Blog: The Kamanga Project
The Kamanga Project
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-SBRjT3X1bUU/U4LuH-alD-I/AAAAAAAAFFQ/9KTdG1VVV54/s1600/640_2014_03_07_10_40_51.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-SBRjT3X1bUU/U4LuH-alD-I/AAAAAAAAFFQ/9KTdG1VVV54/s72-c/640_2014_03_07_10_40_51.jpg
Yadu Karu's Blog
http://www.yadukaru.com/2014/05/the-kamanga-project.html
http://www.yadukaru.com/
http://www.yadukaru.com/
http://www.yadukaru.com/2014/05/the-kamanga-project.html
true
3789680421962388294
UTF-8
Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy