Dreams for Sale: A Study of the Tboli’s Tnalak Industry


   Showcasing of tangible cultural expressions is not new to us. From the Inaul of Maguinadanaon to the Tnalak of Tboli, we are always reminded of their creativity and its link to our cultural heritage. In spite of this recognition, our fellow Indigenous People faces a daunting challenge – the challenge to protect their traditional cultural expressions (e.g. weaving industry) from illicit exploitation and commercialization. 

   The paper discusses how the Tnalak is currently protected under the Philippines sui generis law for indigenous people's protection. It also discusses intellectual property laws and addresses the possibility of applying Human Rights for the protection of TCEs. It also examines and analyses international conventions, treaties and international agreements existing, which the Philippines has signed and ratified and is now part of the national laws of the Philippines by virtue of the incorporation clause in the 1987 Constitution. Moreover, it looks at the sui generis legislations from different countries vis-a-vis the WIPO model law. And lastly, it argues the necessity for a sui generis law for the protection of indigenous intellectual property. 

   The Tbolis are one of the indigenous peoples residing in South Cotabato. The Tbolis are famous for their Tnalak cloth because of its distinctive design. Tnalak is sacred to them and give high importance to it. In recent years, its traditional purposes are slowly diminishing. Because of its economic value, Tnalak becomes their primary source of income. 

   In an interview** of Lang Dulay, the 1998 awardee of the Gawad sa Manlilikha ng Bayan or the National Living Treasure Award conferred by the National Commission for Culture and the Arts (NCCA), she expressed her opinion about the industry of Tnalak. “Most Tnalak sold in the market these days do not conform to the rigid way it should have been processed,” Dulay said.

   Before, it takes time to create a Tnalak, as she said, “One has to make it with deep focus and careful attention to detail—following the precise design, measurement, color, and it should be tight, and the finished product is shiny and smooth to the hands when touched.”

   Because of its demand in the market, its process becomes lessen. As Dulay and her heirs observe, the Tnalak sold in the market are “rough, loose and wobbly abaca hemp, and the smudging colors of red, black and white. Weavers often produce Tnalak in other colors, such as green, blue and brown.”

   Though it violates the essence of Tnalak tradition, she still respects it. As she have stated, “These are the current weavers who rush in making the cloth, but the agenda is solely based on making profit. I can’t blame them, though. They need to live, they have children to feed, and most Tbolis live in poverty.”

   “The demand in the industry is somehow blamed on entrepreneurs who impose their own designs on Tboli weavers to look good on a bags, dresses and accessories.”***

   The Tbolis are not only experiencing this problem. Many Indigenous People in the Philippines are facing the same plight. Indigenous knowledge becomes vulnerable to exploitation by outsiders for commercial profit. In most cases, the outsiders obtained this traditional knowledge without consultation with indigenous communities or any effort to explain how it may be used. As is this problem arises, the communities are demanding for the protection of their knowledge from inappropriate use, emphasizing the need for free, prior and informed consent, and the sharing of benefits. 

   In general, the Intellectual Property Rights of Indigenous Knowledge is problematic and inconsistent. The problem of laws concerning the protection of TCEs is that it is vague and contradictory to other laws in the Philippines. According to Vanguardia “our current intellectual property laws and local legislation on expressions of culture are not sufficient in putting forward the rights of the indigenous people.”

   The author concludes that “the protection of indigenous people's rights is an issue that demonstrates the intersection between our current intellectual property laws as well as the convention on human rights that our nation has committed for its people.” As she have stated, “what might be a solution for one group, the traditionalists, might prove devastating for another group.” She emphasizes that “the protection of TCEs and expressions of culture is not solely the concern of the indigenous people. As a source of our history and cultural heritage, the State also has a duty to protect these expressions of culture, and assist its people in realizing their rights as owners of these expressions of culture.”

   The research of Maria Ester Vanguardia is a good introductory reading for the complex issues of the Tbolis as well as the other Indigenous People in the Philippines. The need to have clear and appropriate methods for the protection of TCEs is clearly stated on her study. More importantly, the rights of our fellow Indigenous People are needed to be exercised and respected. By studying it, we will have an informed decision to make the right action.


* Vanguardia, Maria Ester. Dreams for Sale: Traditional Cultural Expressions (TCEs) and Intellectual Property Rights of the Indigenous Pragmatic Group as Exemplified by the Dreamweavers. 2012 - Philippine Law Journal Online - http://plj.upd.edu.ph/ 
**T’nalak weavers shun commercialization by Rosa May de Guzman-Maitem - http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/28515/t%e2%80%99nalak-weavers-shun-commercialization#ixzz3PFS69n3S
***Rosa May de Guzman-Maitem

Leave a comment below and let me know what you think.
Thank you.


This is the blog of G.V. Alfasain (or popularly known as Yadu Karu) where he shares his thoughts about current events, sustainable development and pop culture. He also shares success stories of modern day heroes to inspire his readers. The author hopes that this blog may contribute change in the (Philippine) society.

action film adventure advertising advocacy Advocates agriculture Alabel anniversary APL-SENTRO apology ARMM Art ASEAN Aswang Ateneo de Davao University audition B'laan BANGSAMORO Bangsi Festival banlas Beach behind the scenes BFAR BIMP-EAGA Binex Financial Times Biography Blaan blog Bloggers bloopers Bo's Coffee Bob Ong book launch book review Books Bourne series boxing Brigada Eskwela Brigada Station Brillante Mindoza British films Business business books Business Chamber BWC calamity CARAT career Carl Jung cashflow CDs chat CHED China vs. Philippines Chiz Escudero Cinema Rehiyon Cinemalaya climate change coal power plant coffee shop comedy film communication community service computer concert conflict consultation contest copper Cotabato City crime Critical analysis culture Cybercrime Law DAR Davao City Davao Region democracy Department of Agriculture Department of Environment and Natural Resources Department of Tourism DepEd Doc Cagape documentary film DOE DOLE DoleFil drama DTI DVDs Economic Development Committee Ecotrek Education Eid al-Fitr Election Elizabethan entrepreneur environment Europe event experiment faith fantasy film farmers Fashion Ferdinand Marcos Festival Filipino books Filipino films film film festival film reviews film workshop filmmaking fishing industry flooding Food trip forum Framework Agreement friend game GAS Generals Generation Change Project Gensan Gensan Doctor's Hospital GenSan Library GenSan Water District Glan gold Google Google Business Group Google Mapping Google Philippines GPH Grace Poe graduate Greenpeace GSCCI Gumasa Beach gun-for-hire HABI HABI Volunteers health heritage holiday Hollywood Holy Trinity College horror film Human Rights Iguoi Production Independence Day Indi film Indigenous People Information Technology international internet interview investing IP Islam job Job Fair joint exercise Jollibee journalism Kabacan kabit Kawas Beach KCC Mall Kiamba Kinam Koronadal City Labor Code Labor Day Lady Gaga Lagao Gym Lake Sebu leadership Lebak LGBT LGU literacy literature Maasim Maguindanao Maitum Malapatan Malaysia Malls Manny Pacquiao Marawi Marin Martial Law Marvel Studio media medical book medical mission meeting message Midsayap MILF Military MinDA Mindanao minerals mining MNLF MSU-GenSan Munato Festival Muslim Muslim Reformist National Bookstore National Sunrise Festival National Youth Commission NCCA netizens networking business news NGO NGOs Nora Aunor North Cotabato Nur Misuari OFW OPAPP open-pit mining opinion opportunity Organic Farming Paco Evangelista Pagadian City Palanca Awards PAMANA PCCI PCOO peace peace agreement People pharma Philippine Government Philippine Heart Center Philippine Heart Foundation philippines photo photo blog photo shoot photography photoJourn PICOS MACHINE Pilipinas Got Talent Pnoy policy Polomolok pop culture Power Crisis praying press release PressCon projects promotional photos propaganda protest psychology books QUEST Ramadan reading Real Estate reality show Region XII Regional Development Council remote areas reporting research Resident Evil resto RH Bill Rodrigo Duterte rollerblades Rudrigo Duterte Sabah SalaMindanaw Asian Film Festival SalaMindanaw Film SalaMindanaw Film Festival SalaMindanaw International Film Festival Sarangani Sarangani Bay Fest Sarangani Big Brother Scarborough Shoal school sci-fi SDS seminar SFFAI Inc. Shakespeare short film SK skaters SM Mall Gensan SM Malls SM Supermarket Gensan small-scale mining SME SMI SOCCSARGEN SOCCSARGEN BLOGGERS SOCCSKSARGEN Social Media SOCOTECO II South China Sea Dispute South Cotabato SOX SOX Reading SOX Reading Advocates SP GenSan SPNI sports Starbucks Sto Niño story strategic plan Sufu Sultan Kudarat Sulu Archipelago Sulu Sultanate Summit Sun City Suites Surallah sustainable developement sustainable development T'nalak festival Tacurong City Talakudong Festival Tampakan Tboli Team Bundol Team PNoy teaser trailer text scare threats Tourism trade travel tree planting tribe Tuanadatu Tuna Tuna Festival Tuna Industry tv typhoon U.P. U.S Embassy U.S.-Philippines Union Union Workers United States University UPRC video Video City vigilant citizen visual art Vlogging Vmobile volunteerism vote Wajahat Ali workshop world World Water Day writing Yadu Karu's Blog Yaman Gensan youth youth development youth empowerment Zamboanga City Zamboanga del Sur zipline zombies
Yadu Karu's Blog: Dreams for Sale: A Study of the Tboli’s Tnalak Industry
Dreams for Sale: A Study of the Tboli’s Tnalak Industry
Yadu Karu's Blog
Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy